19991 Overseas Highway
Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042

PhotosNeighborhoodSchoolsMLS # 579163
Photo of 19991 Overseas Highway, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042
Previous Photo Photo #1Photo #2Photo #3Photo #4Photo #5Photo #6Photo #7Photo #8Photo #9Photo #10Photo #11Photo #12Photo #13Photo #14Photo #15Photo #16Photo #17Photo #18Photo #19Photo #20Photo #21Photo #22Photo #23Photo #24Photo #25Photo #26Photo #27Photo #28Photo #29Photo #30Photo #31Photo #32Photo #33 Next Photo
33 Photos View Larger Photos


A Florida Keys landmark restaurant for sale for only the 2nd time in decades. Mangrove Mamas, world famous even before the Keys legend Howard Livingston wrote a song about it, contains 150 seats, a bar with an SRX liquor license, outside patio area and ample parking. Located directly on US 1, the restaurant is one of the most visible and a must stop location for many Keys events on the way to and from Key West. Restaurant and real estate comes fully equipped and turn-key and has been connected to the new Lower Keys central sewer system. Over $120K in new equipment. Owner will consider a sale, lease or a lease option. Please DO NOT disturb the business or employees.

Property Details

General Info

Property Type: Commercial Property
Bathrooms: 0.4 (0 full, 4 half)
Subdivision: Sugarloaf
County: Monroe
Lot Size: 102,827 Sq Ft.
Year Built: 1919
  • 1 story

Interior Features

  • Central A/C
  • Ceiling fan
  • Concrete
  • Vinyl
  • Tile
  • Fireplace

Exterior Features

Water Front
  • Bay frontage
Misc Exterior Features
  • Utility Shed
  • Patio
Misc Lot Features
  • Highway


  • Shingle

Financial Info


Listing Courtesy of Team Gardner/Langley, Berkshire Hathaway Knight & Gardner Realty (kw)
The information displayed is derived from Florida Keys MLS IDX Listing - Internet Data eXchange
$1,495,000 for sale

Baths0.4 (0 full, 4 half)
Sq. Ft. (total)4,114Lot Size2.361 acres
Get Immediate Assistance
Mon-Thu 9AM-7PM, Fri 9AM-5:30PM, Sat 9AM-5PM, Sun 9AM-4PM
ADDvantage® Real Estate Services

Get Free Property Report

: (required)
Info Requested:
Availability of listing (status)
Ownership (short-sale, etc)
HOA Fees
Vacant or owner occupied
Lot size
Details to make an offer
Would you like to be notified
by email when similar listings
come on the market?

Are you currently working with another real estate Agent?: Yes   No

Note: We keep the information you enter private. We do not sell your info to anyone, nor do we send you spam messages. You may view our privacy policy here.
Map Loading…

Driving Directions 19991 Overseas Highway, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042

Additional Map Options:

Other Listings Nearby

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should not be relied upon without independent verification. Listing information is provided for personal, non-commercial use; all other use is strictly prohibited.
ADDvantage Real Estate will help sell a home by listing homes for sale or for rent in any Florida MLS including Miami, Tampa, Jacksonville, and Orlando. We are the number one choice in Florida for Flat Fee MLS and full-service covering Sugarloaf Key, Monroe county, and many more cities. ADDvantage is the only By Owner MLS listing service in Florida that guarantees all calls will be answered live by a MLS administrator from Mon-Thu 9AM-7PM, Fri 9AM-5:30PM, Sat 9AM-5PM, Sun 9AM-4PM and that all buyer leads from FSBO sites such as Homes.com, Realtor.com, Trulia, Zillow, and GetMoreOffers will be sent to the seller in real time by email. Call us anytime at 727-942-2929 or 1-877-232-9695.